Why you know every word and still can't read the sentence

What you miss is not a word but the relations between words

The meaning of a long English sentence is not the meanings of its words added up in a row. Who does what, to whom, under which condition, unless what happens: these relations are set by a few small words, such as must, unless, that, which and based on. A dictionary cannot look up a relation, so every word is known and the relations stay empty.

A long sentence is nested, not a straight line

A fluent reader of “The tenant must give the landlord written notice at least thirty days before moving out, unless the lease ends earlier” first takes hold of “the tenant must give the landlord notice”, then hangs “at least thirty days”, “before moving out” and “unless the lease ends earlier” on it, one layer at a time. A reader who goes word by word has forgotten the subject by the tenth word.

A word's meaning is fixed by its place in the structure

In a contract, shall is an obligation; in conversation, it is a suggestion. That can point at a thing or open a whole clause. Based introduces the premise of the entire sentence. Until you see the place, the meaning you look up is often the wrong one.

So the difference between a fluent reader and you is not vocabulary. It is one thing they do without thinking: structure first, then meaning.

Three steps: structure first, then meaning

  1. Find the trunk

    The trunk is the shortest run of words that still says what the sentence says: usually the subject, the main verb and what the verb requires. Find the verb of the main clause first, then the subject that goes with it. In the contract sentence the trunk is “The tenant must give the landlord written notice”. With that, the skeleton of the whole sentence is in your hands.

  2. Find the cue words and hang the rest on the trunk

    Every part outside the trunk hangs on it through a cue word: unless, although, which, before, based on. The cue word tells you which question that part answers. Before what? Unless what? Based on what? Once you see the cue, you know where the part belongs, with no guessing.

  3. Hold the anchors, then check the meaning

    In each part only one or two content words carry the weight: notice, thirty days, lease. Hold those anchors, say what the part means in one sentence in the language you choose, and check it against the original. At this point the sentence you just said is the proof that you have read it.

This is what InterStand draws on the sentence: the trunk on green, cue words underlined, anchors in bold, one line per part with a gloss in the language you choose. The marks are the same every time and on every page, until you can see them yourself.

Three real long sentences, walked through

All three come from public texts. The analysis was made by the product's own pipeline and is shown as it came out after a native reviewer passed it. Follow the link to see the structure drawn on the tool page.

A contract clause: unless hides the condition at the end

The tenant must give the landlord written notice at least thirty days before moving out, unless the lease ends earlier.

Where readers get stuckBy the time you reach unless, the obligation has already been read, and many readers skip the rest as a side note.

Walk-throughThe trunk is “the tenant must give the landlord written notice”. At least thirty days answers “how many days at least”; before moving out answers “before what”. Then unless the lease ends earlier is a condition that rewrites the whole sentence: if the lease ends early, the obligation no longer applies. In a contract, cue words like unless, provided that and except must always be read to the end.

A news sentence: the real content comes after estimate that

Scientists estimate that an impact of this magnitude happens on the Moon about once in a century or even longer.

Where readers get stuckScientists estimate looks like the trunk, but it only says who is estimating.

Walk-throughThe that in estimate that opens the content of the estimate: “an impact of this magnitude happens” is what the sentence is really about. The two parts after it each answer one question. Where? On the Moon. How often? About once in a century or even longer. Once you see that, you know where the real content begins.

A paper abstract: two participle phrases, one fact each

We propose a new simple network architecture, the Transformer, based solely on attention mechanisms, dispensing with recurrence and convolutions entirely.

Where readers get stuckAfter the commas, based and dispensing have no subject of their own, and a word-by-word reader cannot tell what they are about.

Walk-throughThe trunk is “we propose a new network architecture”; the Transformer is its name. Based solely on attention mechanisms answers “based on what”; dispensing with recurrence and convolutions answers “doing without what”. Both participle phrases hang on the architecture and state two facts about the same thing. Almost every sentence of a paper abstract is built this way.

Three common wrong turns

  1. Translating word by word

    Replacing each word with one in your language and stringing them together gives you a row of words, not a sentence. The relations were never translated, so you finish and still do not understand.

  2. Looking up every word before reading

    When vocabulary is not the bottleneck, ten more lookups will not help. Find the trunk first; many of the words never need looking up.

  3. Going straight to a translation

    A translation gives you the answer and takes the sentence away. The next sentence is as hard as before. Once you see the structure, the next sentence gets easier.

Next

Read the pre-analyzed examples on the tool page

Free to read, no account needed.

Open the tool page

Analyze your own sentence in the web reader

Paste text or open a PDF; nothing to install.

Open the web reader

Use the Chrome extension on any page

Select the sentence where you read it and the structure is drawn right there.

Add to Chrome

Every new account has 10 free uses a month for the first 3 months, no card required.

Frequently asked questions

Why can't I understand an English sentence when I know every word?

Because the meaning is not in the single words but in the relations between them. The relations are set by the trunk and the cue words, which a dictionary cannot look up. Structure first, then meaning.

What is the trunk of a sentence?

The shortest run of words that still says what the sentence says: usually the subject, the main verb and what the verb requires. Reading the trunk first is what fluent readers do without thinking.

What is a cue word?

A word that opens a clause or phrase and tells you which question that part answers: unless, although, which, before, based on, provided that.

Does this only work for long sentences?

It works for short ones too; you just do not need to do it on purpose. In long sentences, papers, contracts and regulations, these three steps are the way to read that works every time.

Do I need to learn grammar terms first?

No. Each part answers one question: who? must do what? unless what? The questions are written in the language you choose.

Who analyzed these example sentences?

The product's own pipeline. Only sentences a native reviewer passed are shown; a misread one is taken down.

Know Every Word but Can't Understand the Sentence? | InterStand